web analytics

The Tablet 15 May 2004

… This excellent volume is a history of the first half century or so of the order.

None of which is at all remarkable, and the book would possibly not have merited a review, had not Dr Liebreich’s researches (the text has the air of being a doctoral thesis happily recast into highly readable prose) revealed a great deal of the distinctly murky history of the order’s beginnings. Amid the murk, and to the delight of the media, she has uncovered sexual abuse of their pupils by a handful of the early Piarist fathers, and Joseph Calasanz’s efforts to cover up the abuse and avoid scandal by moving offenders to other posts.

… And there [with the appointment of Cherubini] the book ends, except for a wholly unnecessary chapter retelling the Catholic Church’s contemporary problems with child abuse. The publicity surrounding this account has concentrated on the sexual deviance of a (very small) group of Scolopi clergy. The author herself makes a great deal of the contemporary reference. She has hopped on to the bandwagon. But the book is more important as a revealing account, not so much of seventeenth-century sexual deviance, but of the travails of the early years of an important religious order.

Michael Walsh

The site is currently undergoing maintenance so some features may not be working as expected. Apologies for the inconvenience.

Maintenance should be complete on Monday 11th November.